We recommend using TastyPins to manage your Pinterest pins.
Why we don’t build Pinterest functionality into themes
WordPress themes are designed for aesthetics – visual styling that should be timeless. Formatting content for Pinterest is functional, and belongs in a paid plugin that is regularly update. For more information, see this post.
Pinterest changes their “preferred” format multiple times per year, with each update causing some bloggers to gain traffic, and others to lose traffic. Over the past year alone we’ve seen bloggers comment on:
- Increased traffic when switching to rich pins
- Decreased traffic when switching to rich pins
- Increased traffic from long pins
- Decreased traffic from long pins
- Increased traffic from increased pinning frequency
- Accounts banned from increased pinning frequency
These changes fluctuate more than a teenagers voice going through puberty, and we simply don’t have the time or the incentive to stay on top of this.
As a general principle, we believe that your efforts should have a long term payoff, which just isn’t possible with social media. Companies like Pinterest and Facebook benefit from constantly shifting their algorithm to increase pageviews on THEIR site, not yours. Because of this, anything you do on social media websites is likely going to disappear within 2-3 years. This is not an acceptable return on time to us.
Our belief is that you should be focused on creating content FOR YOUR BLOG, which you have control over for life.
When SHOULD you use Pinterest?
Pinterest is a legit source of traffic, and for blogs that monetize via display ads, there’s a direct correlation between traffic (pageviews on your blog) and income. In cases where you stand to make a return on your time by investing in Pinterest, we recommend investing in TastyPins.